Back in the days of my parents and Pat Mitchell (Cutlers) we had a model called the P1, it was a standard in our range and was by far and away the best selling knife in our portfolio.
From an old catalogue back then; P1, Compact Hunter, 2.75” blade and 6.25” overall, an extremely compact practical knife suitable for a wide variety of tasks from skinning to stick dressing and carving, Produced from 1/8" stock steel making it also a lightweight backpackers tool.
I was intrigued and delighted in equal measure when I received this message; A recent post of yours got me thinking, I wondered if you would care to re-imagine the ‘P1’ that I’ve carried with me for the last 30 years, and make me your version for the next. I would like similar dimensions and as I spend many an hour in uncomfortable high seats I’d like a horizontal sheath.
The Portland Series to which the P1 belonged signalled a change of approach for us, the significant difference to the other knives we were making at this time being that it had no metal bolsters, it was designed and made this way to reduce costs, not so much material costs but more labour, saving workshop hours and so saving our customers, the end users, money.
I was heavily involved in it's concept and design and if I were designing it today this new version knife would very likely be it. The slight problem with that is that the new version unticks a few boxes, the design and shaping of the handle makes it a more complicated thing to make, that adds a bit of time back on and so adding to the cost, a very anti Portland Series ethic.
The profile is exactly the same as an original, the new one in fact was scribed on to the 1/8” thick Silver Fox steel using the same template as my clients 30 year old example, that is pretty cool.
Omitting the large sharpening nick in favour of a much more discreet version allows more blade edge from the same size blade.
The new one gets fully stabilised Walnut for the scales, offcuts supplied by a very well known gun maker, old version would predominantly have been Rosewood or Cocobolo, those scales are fitted over red liners and a tapering tang this time too, again very un Portland Series, but hey ho, we live in different days.
I only have one P1 in the workshop and it is an unfinished version which has great sentimental value to me as is so I will never finish it, it is also the 'hook' version which although very Marmite was still an extremely popular knife, the side by side shot will give an idea of the main differences though.
What a pleasure this project has been.